Layoffs, Redundancies and Restructures - Your Rights and Next Steps
Our guide helps anyone recently laid off or going through a restructure understand what to do. It covers essential tips and resources for handling restructures and redundancies in New Zealand.
Updated 7 July 2024
Summary
Important: Restructuring, redundancy and layoffs aren’t the same concepts, but for the purposes of the rest of the guide we’ll bucket them into a similar category given they are all related. For further details, we suggest reading these guides and resources:
Related MoneyHub guides:
- As higher interest rates put more pressure on private businesses, coupled with government cutbacks, more New Zealanders than ever have been thrust into a period of employment uncertainty.
- There’s a good chance that at some point in your career, you’re almost guaranteed to go through a restructure or get laid off. Many New Zealanders will currently be actively going through or be told about impending restructures that are happening all around the country.
- Naturally, if you haven’t been through the restructure process before it can be extremely daunting and scary. However, don’t panic - there are things you can do to come out of the restructure stronger than ever before.
- In New Zealand, restructures must follow a specific process and can be extremely complex. Restructuring involves careful planning (on the part of the employer), clear communication, and adherence to legal obligations. Employers must ensure that they follow a fair and transparent process to maintain trust and minimise disruption within the organisation and to affected employees.
- While it’s great that New Zealanders are very relaxed in a work and hiring context, often, employers can be a bit blasé about restructures (especially if they’re a smaller start-up or if they haven’t gone through layoffs before).
- This guide lays out the mandatory things you should expect in a restructure (and if they’re not being undertaken by your employer, know what your recourse/steps are to rectify these issues). We cover:
- Preparing for a Layoff: Essential Strategies to Navigate Restructures Successfully
- When Do Businesses and Organisations Go Through Restructures? Why Do They Restructure Rather Than Alternatives?
- Identifying Early Warning Signs That a Business Might Be Preparing for a Restructure
- New Zealanders Most at Risk of Layoffs Right Now - Our View
- Understanding the Restructure Process under New Zealand Law
- Pros and Cons of Getting Laid Off
- Must-Know Facts Related to Layoffs, Redundancies and Restructures
Important: Restructuring, redundancy and layoffs aren’t the same concepts, but for the purposes of the rest of the guide we’ll bucket them into a similar category given they are all related. For further details, we suggest reading these guides and resources:
- Redundancy Payouts and Entitlements
- Redundancy Insurance
- NZHerald - Career experts: What to do if facing redundancy
- MBIE - NZIIS Financial support is provided for most jobs losses
- Work and Income - Redundancy support
Related MoneyHub guides:
MoneyHub Founder Christopher Walsh shares his views and suggestions:
"Experiencing a layoff or restructure can be a deeply unsettling time, filled with uncertainty and stress. I know it's happening widely in all corners of New Zealand right now - in the first week of July I received three 'I'm moving on' emails from contacts at different companies in varying industries. If you are concerned about your future, first and foremost, ensure that you understand your rights and the legal processes involved. New Zealand law clearly states that employers must follow a fair and transparent procedure during restructures, which includes proper consultation and the opportunity for employees to provide feedback. Re-read your employment agreement and the steps your employer must take. Remember, layoffs and restructures are often out of your control and are not a reflection of your abilities or worth. Our guide is published to walk you through what you need to know so you can take action and have more control in the process. For many, it will be the first time they have to deal with such uncertainty, but as it's happening more and more, a lot of resources are available, and help is on hand". |
Christopher Walsh
MoneyHub Founder |
Know This First: Legal considerations to be aware of:
Whatever is happening with your job and/or your workplace, please be aware of the following:
1. Your employment agreement takes priority
New Zealand Employers must adhere to the terms and conditions set out in employment agreements, including notice periods and redundancy entitlements. If they don’t, you have a legitimate claim against them in employment court. Make sure you carefully read and re-review your Individual Employment Agreement once finding out about the restructure to ensure they follow the commercial and contractual obligations they owe to you.
2. Make sure your employers are negotiating in good faith.
Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, employers are required to act in good faith, meaning they must be open, honest, and communicative throughout the process. If they’re actively not doing so (or you expect they’re not), document the entire journey (including outlining where they are not negotiating in good faith) and take this to either an employment lawyer or a free law service (like a Community Law Centre) to progress the matter further.
3. You have options if you think you’ve been unfairly dismissed
Employees who feel they have been unfairly treated or that the process was flawed can raise a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal. These claims must be raised within 90 days of the issue arising (e.g. once you’ve realised it’s happened) - so it’s recommended to act sooner rather than later on these matters per guidance from Employment New Zealand.
Important: Is a restructure the same as a redundancy?
A restructure can mean changing roles or responsibilities (and doesn’t always mean a job is lost), but a redundancy always results in job loss or a termination of employment contracts. For example:
1. Your employment agreement takes priority
New Zealand Employers must adhere to the terms and conditions set out in employment agreements, including notice periods and redundancy entitlements. If they don’t, you have a legitimate claim against them in employment court. Make sure you carefully read and re-review your Individual Employment Agreement once finding out about the restructure to ensure they follow the commercial and contractual obligations they owe to you.
2. Make sure your employers are negotiating in good faith.
Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, employers are required to act in good faith, meaning they must be open, honest, and communicative throughout the process. If they’re actively not doing so (or you expect they’re not), document the entire journey (including outlining where they are not negotiating in good faith) and take this to either an employment lawyer or a free law service (like a Community Law Centre) to progress the matter further.
3. You have options if you think you’ve been unfairly dismissed
Employees who feel they have been unfairly treated or that the process was flawed can raise a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal. These claims must be raised within 90 days of the issue arising (e.g. once you’ve realised it’s happened) - so it’s recommended to act sooner rather than later on these matters per guidance from Employment New Zealand.
Important: Is a restructure the same as a redundancy?
- No, a restructure is not the same as a redundancy, though they are related and often occur together.
- In New Zealand, a restructure involves changes to a company’s organisational structure. This can include reorganising departments, changing roles, streamlining operations and changes in strategic direction. The aim of a restructure is to enhance the overall performance and competitiveness of the business. Restructuring may not necessarily lead to job losses but often does involve changes in roles and responsibilities.
- In contrast, redundancy in New Zealand specifically refers to the termination of an employee’s job due to the role being no longer needed. This can occur due to a business closing down, cost-cutting measures or the specific role not being needed in the wider business function.
- Often, a company will start out with a proposed restructure, where a redundancy is the next logical step (assuming the ultimate outcome is that a redundancy is necessary). A restructure is usually high level, a redundancy is employee (or a specific segment of employees) specific.
A restructure can mean changing roles or responsibilities (and doesn’t always mean a job is lost), but a redundancy always results in job loss or a termination of employment contracts. For example:
- Restructure without Redundancy: A company merges two departments but retains all employees by reallocating roles.
- Restructure leading to Redundancy: A company streamlines operations by automating tasks, leading to job redundancies in manual processing roles.
Preparing for a Layoff: Essential Strategies to Navigate Restructures Successfully
Our suggestions below are best carried out with speed, given the financial implications of not having a pay day while you're out of work.
1. Start looking and applying for jobs ASAP
2. Start cutting household costs ASAP
3. Be kind to yourself
1. Start looking and applying for jobs ASAP
- Don’t wait and hope your employer will keep you around. The best way to prepare for the future is to assume the worst and start updating your CV and LinkedIn profile.
- While you’re still employed and going through the consultation process for the restructure, start networking and job searching for your next role. Reach out to your professional network for job leads and opportunities on websites like Seek and LinkedIn to find job openings. Also consider registering with recruitment agencies that specialise in your industry.
- Update your CV with the recent highlights (including your skills, achievements, and experience that you’ve obtained from the most recent role) and try to obtain recommendations from colleagues and supervisors in advance.
2. Start cutting household costs ASAP
- If you’re laid off, you’ll get your final payslip that includes an accrued holiday pay and leave balances (contractually based on employment law) but you’re likely to go through a severe income drop. If you’re planning trips and still have lots of discretionary spend, now is the time to taper that off.
- Plan to jump on the jobseeker benefit as soon as you are unemployed - it’s free money (that you partially paid for via your taxes) and that’s exactly what the jobseeker benefit is designed for - supporting New Zealanders while they’re looking for jobs.
3. Be kind to yourself
- A restructure is an incredibly traumatic time. Almost nobody expects to be laid off and out of the job - but it happens often.
- Whether it’s a friend who’s gone through the process or a family member that can provide a bit of support, it’s absolutely okay to lean on your network at a time like this.
- There are also counselling services (like EAP) that your workplace might offer - it’s free to you or subsidised by your work so we’d recommend absolutely taking them up on that. Try to maintain a sense of routine, exercise, and engage in activities that you enjoy while going through the process to take your mind off things.
When Do Businesses and Organisations Go Through Restructures? Why Do They Restructure Rather Than Alternatives?
Businesses and organisations may go through restructures for a variety of reasons, often driven by the need to adapt to internal and external pressures. The most popular reasons for restructurings are:
Financial DifficultiesBusinesses are notoriously cyclical. If a business goes through a tough period and experiences a significant drop in revenue or profitability, restructuring may be necessary to cut costs and remain viable. This was very common during COVID-19, where hospitality businesses effectively had their revenue drop to zero overnight (but still had high operating costs such as staff costs, office or premises leases and other financial obligations). While there were some subsidies provided (like the COVID wage subsidy), businesses were still struggling even after this support.
Another culprit for financial difficulties is debt. High levels of debt or financial obligations can prompt restructuring to manage or reduce debt. For example, businesses that took out ultra-low business loans when interest rates were near-zero in 2020 will now be paying 3X to 4X their interest payments in 2024 (as the RBNZ increased the OCR from 0.25% to 5.5% over a few years). This overleveraging or “businesses getting over their skis” can cause serious pressure on a company’s financials (prompting drastic cost-cutting measures such as restructures). |
Competition and Market ChangesBusiness is a competitive field. As more new entrants try to compete for the same customers, it can impact on profitability. Increased competition (e.g. a new bakery opens up across the street from your own bakery) might necessitate a change in business strategy, leading to restructuring.
Additionally, if you’re in a line of business that’s particularly prone to economic downturns or recessions, it can force businesses to restructure to survive. For example, if you have two full time bakers and used to sell 100 pies a day, but due to the cost of living crisis you only sell 40 pies a day, you suddenly no longer need a second baker. Due to New Zealand labour laws, employers can't tell the second baker to not come into work - they must follow a clear process to restructure your existing labour force. While this adds a short term cost and time sink for the business, it’s much more palatable for the employee (knowing they can’t just get fired at a moment’s notice like in other countries). |
Technological AdvancementsRecent advancements in AI (such as the introduction of Open AI’s Chat GPT to the mass market) in recent years have meant that many businesses (especially those operating in white collar industries) are able to be far more efficient than previously before.
For example, a company that makes $1 million in revenue with 10 employees may only need 6 employees plus a Chat GPT subscription, depending on the industry it operates in. Unfortunately, this means that many New Zealanders who are currently employed may be at risk of getting laid off (redundancy) and may struggle to find another job (if the changes are systemic and impacting all firms in the industry). Our view is simple: As technology innovation occurs, more tools get created that streamline and operate business operations (leading to less staff requirements). |
Mergers and AcquisitionsInevitably as companies go through business cycles, some companies consolidate, merge or are acquired by rivals, leading to organisational changes. In particular, many companies choose to go through restructuring to streamline and integrate the operations of the two companies (especially if there are heavily overlapping functions, such as human resources, finance, marketing, operations, etc.).
Mergers and acquisitions usually involve strategy refreshes and lead to new management or direction (meaning the old cultures of each respective firm can take a hit). |
Government and Regulatory ChangesWhile uncommon, sometimes, new laws or regulations may require businesses to change their structures to comply with legal standards. Changes in industry practices or standards can also drive restructuring.
More common is a change of government, whereby a government department is informed of a headcount cap (led by legislation or ministerial direction) that limits a certain number of employees per organisation. This then leads to a headcount reduction. |
​Operational InefficienciesSometimes businesses let their costs get a little bloated (especially when there’s lots of business and money flowing). However, companies can sometimes overhire and realise they need to cut back on expenses.
Identifying and eliminating inefficiencies in operations can lead to restructuring (for the ultimate purpose of creating a more profitable, lean efficient). While it may hurt the business in the short term (specifically with team culture and morale), it’s better for the business in the long term. |
Management or Leadership ChangesMany new executives that come into businesses try to make drastic changes early on in their tenure to “turn the ship in the right direction”, especially if they were brought in to fix a struggling company. As a result, restructures commonly follow new management or leadership.
Additionally, a new CEO or management team may initiate restructuring to align the organisation with their vision and strategy. Whether it’s a new market segment they want to tackle, improve profitability within a business unit or try to improve the existing products or services they provide, new CEOs are more motivated to act than CEOs that have been around for a while. |
​Reshuffling HeadcountSometimes, businesses that operate in different markets (e.g. they have products that sell/ship to New Zealand as well as Australia) find that they get more traction in one market over the other. IF the teams are hired locally, this can mean that more budget or headcount makes sense in one country rather than the other (which can lead to restructuring to redistribute headcount in the places where it makes the most sense).
Equally, if a company is entering a new market, but doesn’t have the budget to keep the old headcount, restructuring to allow the expansion into the new geographic or product market might make sense. Unexpected crises, such as natural disasters (like the Christchurch Earthquakes) or pandemics (like COVID-19, can force businesses to restructure to adapt to new realities (like a drastic drop in revenue or an inability to maintain the existing cost structure). Equally, if a business goes through a scandal or some other issue, reputational damage or legal issues might require changes in business structure (such as a restructure). |
Crisis ManagementUnexpected crises, such as natural disasters (like the Christchurch Earthquakes) or pandemics (like COVID-19, can force businesses to restructure to adapt to new realities (like a drastic drop in revenue or an inability to maintain the existing cost structure). Equally, if a business goes through a scandal or some other issue, reputational damage or legal issues might require changes in business structure (such as a restructure).
|
Identifying Early Warning Signs That a Business Might Be Preparing for a Restructure
Often, restructures don’t come as a complete shock. There are some early warning signs that might suggest a restructure is headed your way:
Communication to StakeholdersThis is the most obvious sign that a restructure or round of layoffs are coming. Increased communication with employees and stakeholders is another sign that restructuring may be on the horizon (particularly if this news or update is focused on cost-cutting or suggests the business is struggling). Internal memos discussing upcoming changes or strategic reviews can prepare the workforce for transitions. Similarly, frequent meetings with investors, shareholders, and other key stakeholders to discuss future plans may indicate that significant organisational changes are being considered.
Often, layoffs and restructuring will occur after the new financial year goals and budgets are set (rather than halfway through the year when teams and management are still trying to deliver on the budget and plan that’s already been set). |
Reduced Social Activities and Communication Within Your TeamIt’s extremely difficult to lay off people you’re deeply connected to and spend a lot of time with. If you start to notice that some of your team members (particularly your direct managers) are being distant or not connecting/interacting with you as much as they previously did (e.g. less team days or coffee catch-ups), this could be a sign they are actively preparing a restructure and either feel bad (so don’t want to get too close to you while it goes on) or actively want to create some distance before they give you the bad news.
|
Executive Leadership ChangesWhen a business is gearing up for restructuring, one of the most telling signs is changes in leadership. This can include the appointment of new executives or the introduction of a turnaround specialist whose expertise lies in navigating companies through significant transitions. Additionally, the sudden or strategic departure of key executives may also indicate a shift in the company’s strategic direction, often as part of a broader plan to revitalise the business.
|
Financial Performance Reviews (Daily Standups, Quarterly Benchmarking, Tracking Deliverables)Another clear indicator of impending restructuring is the frequency and intensity of financial performance reviews. Businesses may begin to scrutinise their financial health more closely, conducting detailed and frequent reporting on the efficiency of existing employees. Cost-cutting measures are often implemented to improve financial stability, suggesting that the company is preparing to make significant changes to its operations and structure.
Important: Employers cannot restructure you out specifically due to your performance in your role alone. This is a separate process known as a Performance Improvement Process (PIP) and must be strictly followed. Laying off people in a restructure as a result of poor performance is grounds for unfair dismissal (as we outline more in detail below). |
Operational ChangesReorganisation within the company’s departments can also signal restructuring. This may involve the merging of departments or the reallocation of resources to optimise efficiency. Comprehensive reviews of existing processes and systems are often conducted to identify and address inefficiencies, laying the groundwork for a more streamlined and effective operation post-restructure.
|
Hiring Freeze (especially at the graduate level)Changes within the human resources department can be particularly telling. The implementation of hiring freezes or a noticeable slowdown in recruitment efforts often precedes workforce adjustments. If your current company isn’t hiring, it’s likely they aren’t confident there’s enough work or capacity required to deliver on the future workstreams (which could mean there’s excess people within your current team structure).
Additionally, offering voluntary retirement or exit programs, or announcing layoffs (similar to the news that’s come out of the 2024 National Cabinet plans), can be clear indicators that the company is restructuring its human capital to align with new strategic objectives. |
When a Business Hires External ConsultantsHiring external consultants or advisory firms to assist with strategic reviews and restructuring plans is another key sign. These experts bring in an outside perspective and specialised knowledge that can guide the company through the complex process of restructuring. Industry rumours and increased speculation about potential restructuring can also provide external clues about a company’s internal plans.
|
New Zealanders Most at Risk of Layoffs Right Now - Our View
Certain industries are naturally more prone to restructures, redundancies, and layoffs due to various factors such as economic cycles, technological advancements, and changes in consumer behaviour:
​New Zealanders working in vulnerable industries
|
Employees in support functions
|
Older Workers
|
Blue Collar Workers
|
Contract, Temporary or Part Time WorkersContract, part time and temporary workers typically face higher job insecurity compared to permanent employees. During periods of economic uncertainty or restructuring, companies and organisations often reduce their reliance on temporary staff first, as it’s a quicker and less legally complicated way to cut costs. These workers are usually not entitled to the same benefits or job protections as full-time employees, making them more vulnerable to layoffs.
|
Employees in Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)Workers employed by small and medium enterprises can be at greater risk during economic downturns or industry disruptions. SMEs generally have fewer financial reserves and less flexibility to absorb economic shocks compared to larger corporations. As a result, they may need to reduce staff more quickly and extensively to stay afloat during challenging times.
|
Those newly hiredRecently hired employees (especially those within their 90 days/three month probation/trial period) may also be more vulnerable to layoffs. During restructuring, companies often operate on a "last in, first out" principle, prioritising the retention of more tenured staff who have deeper institutional knowledge and have proven their value over time. New hires, who have not yet had the chance to fully establish themselves, may be more expendable in the eyes of the organization.
|
Remote WorkersEmployees located in remote or geographically isolated areas might face higher risks of layoffs, especially if their roles are not critical to the company's core operations (or they have far less facetime with the managers they’re working with, making them easier to “cut”). Companies might consolidate operations to more central locations to reduce logistical costs and improve efficiency, leaving those in less accessible areas more vulnerable to job cuts.
|
Workers in declining sectorsEmployees in industries facing long-term decline or undergoing significant disruption are particularly at risk. Sectors like traditional or legacy media (e.g. Newshub and TVNZ), print publishing, and fossil fuels are examples where the demand is shrinking due to technological advancements and changing consumer preferences. Workers in these industries may find themselves more frequently facing layoffs as companies downsize or pivot to new business models.
|
Understanding the Restructure Process under New Zealand Law
In New Zealand, the process of restructuring involves several key steps that employers must follow to ensure compliance with employment laws (as outlined by Business.govt.nz) and to treat employees fairly. The typical restructure is broken up into six key steps:
1. Planning and Rationale
2. Consultation with Employees
3. Consideration of Feedback
4. Decision Making
5. Implementation
6. Follow-Up
1. Planning and Rationale
- Identify the Business Need: The first step is identifying the need for restructuring, which could be due to financial pressures, changes in business direction, technological advancements, or other strategic reasons. Without a clear need to restructure, employers can’t just lay people off.
- Develop a Business Case: Employers should prepare a detailed business case outlining the reasons for the restructure, the objectives, and the proposed changes. Usually, this is a few pages in length. There’s no “minimum” business case length, but it should clearly articulate some of the key points of the business need.
2. Consultation with Employees
- Initial Notification: New Zealand employers must inform employees about the potential restructure and the reasons behind it. This is often done through an in-person meeting and followed up with written communication. Often, employers will put something ominous in the employee’s calendar like “Organisational Update” or “Business Update”. Employers don’t have to give you any forewarning before they come out with this proposal (with some employers anecdotally setting these initial notification meetings as soon as people come back from leave - which is particularly quite brutal).
- Provide Proposal: A detailed proposal should be provided to employees, including information on the affected roles, the proposed changes and the potential impact on employees.
- Consultation Period: Employers must engage in a meaningful consultation process, allowing employees to provide feedback and ask questions. This period should be sufficient to give employees a genuine opportunity to influence the decision. Often, this period lasts for anywhere from a few weeks to a few months (depending on how extensive the nature of the restructure).
3. Consideration of Feedback
- Review Feedback: Employers must genuinely consider all feedback received from employees during the consultation period. This involves assessing the viability of any suggestions or alternatives proposed by employees. There will be at least one (but sometimes more) opportunities to provide feedback on the proposed restructure.
- Modify Proposal if Necessary: Based on the feedback, the employer may need to adjust the original proposal. This shows that the consultation was meaningful and taken seriously (however, often employers will come up with reasons why the feedback has already been taken into account or isn’t effective - especially if they are hell bent on doing the layoff).
4. Decision Making
- Final Decision: After considering feedback, the employer makes a final decision on the restructuring. This should be documented clearly and communicated to all employees. Often, this will happen rather swiftly once the final feedback has been incorporated into the proposed restructure.
- Notify Employees: Employees should be informed about the final decision and how it will affect them. This includes providing information on any changes to roles, redundancy processes, and support available. At this point, you’ll likely find out whether your role is disestablished, you’ve been put on notice period or you’ll need to apply for the new role they’ve created (if applicable).
5. Implementation
- Redundancy Process: If redundancies are necessary, the employer must follow fair processes, including offering redeployment options if possible (like moving employees into new roles under different teams or divisions - but don’t expect this as a certainty), providing notice periods as per employment agreements, and offering redundancy compensation (although this is not normally the case in New Zealand unless explicitly in your employment contract or if the employer provides this as a sign of good faith - in contrast, Australia has legislated redundancy payout provisions).
- Support Services: Employers should offer support services such as career counselling, outplacement services, and emotional support to affected employees (not only throughout the restructure process but also once the decision has been made regarding the outcome of the restructure).
6. Follow-Up
- Monitoring and Support: Post-restructure, employers should monitor the impact of the changes and provide ongoing support to remaining employees to ensure smooth transition and maintenance of morale.
Pros and Cons of Getting Laid Off
While getting laid off is (for many) one of the toughest, most challenging and stressful work situations to be placed in, there are a few silver linings that can come from the situation. We explain the pros and cons to help you plan.
Pros:
Cons:
While there are some potential silver linings to being laid off, there are obviously several significant drawbacks:
Pros:
- Financial compensation: Often, some firms will offer severance pay (either due to contractual obligations or in good faith) that can provide a few months of financial cushion while you look for a new job. In some cases, you may receive redundancy pay, which can help manage expenses during your transition.
- Provide a clean way to make a career transition: Being laid off can be just the push you need to explore new job opportunities, industries, or roles that you may not have considered otherwise. Often, it’s all too easy to get stuck in a routine and not take the “risk” with a move into an industry or area that you really want to try, but can’t due to the cushy salary you’d be walking away from.
- Starting your own business: Alternatively, many New Zealanders are entrepreneurial and would love to try to become their own boss - but just struggle to find the right time. If you’ve ever considered starting your own business, a layoff can be the catalyst to pursue entrepreneurial ventures. If you’re a few decades into your career, many choose to go freelancing or consulting, which can offer flexibility and control over your work. Getting laid off can be a perfect way to transition to one of these options.
- Pursue personal growth or travel: The time after you’ve been laid off can be used to upskill or gain new certifications, which can make you more competitive in the job market. Layoffs provide an opportunity for self-reflection and reassessment of your career goals and personal aspirations. Often, many young New Zealanders choose to travel after getting laid off too. Whether it’s the three months backpacking around Europe or Asia that they could never find the time to get annual leave approved for, New Zealanders can finally take those one in a lifetime experiences they wanted to take.
- Retire early: Some New Zealanders are lucky enough to have saved a significant sum throughout their career and just needed that push to enter retirement early (e.g. early or mid 50s). If you were hesitant to pull the trigger on FIRE (Financial Independence Retire Early) but had the finances to do so - a restructure and redundancy is a perfect Segway into the next stage of your life.
- Move offshore: Without the tie to your current job, you might consider relocating to a new city or country for better job opportunities or quality of life (e.g. Australia, the UK or Asia).
Cons:
While there are some potential silver linings to being laid off, there are obviously several significant drawbacks:
- Financial uncertainty (and the lack of income): The immediate loss of a steady paycheck can lead to financial instability, making it difficult to meet living expenses and financial obligations. Without a regular income, you may need to dip into savings, which can affect long-term financial goals and security. While unemployment benefits (e.g. jobseeker) can provide some relief, they may not fully replace your previous income and are usually limited in duration.
- Emotional and psychological impact: The uncertainty of finding new employment and managing financial responsibilities can lead to significant stress and anxiety. For many people, their job is a significant part of their identity. Losing a job can lead to a sense of loss and affect self-esteem. The challenges of being laid off can contribute to feelings of depression, particularly if the job search process is prolonged (or the job market is in a period of prolonged downturn).
- Career disruption: A layoff creates a gap in your employment history, which can be viewed negatively by some potential employers. If you remain unemployed for an extended period, there is a risk that your skills may become outdated, especially in rapidly evolving industries. We recommend trying to frame it on the CV as a “travel break”, sabbatical or mid-career break. Alternatively, opting for consulting may help to alleviate this gap on the CV (however, many employers view breaks as a positive thing).
- Impact on professional relationships: Losing daily interaction with colleagues can be difficult, particularly if you’re extroverted, had strong professional relationships and relied on teamwork. While layoffs can push you to network more, they can also make it harder to maintain relationships with former colleagues who may be focused on their own job security.
- Health and wellbeing concerns: Getting laid off can increase stress and anxiety which can negatively impact physical health, leading to issues such as sleep disturbances, high blood pressure, and other stress-related conditions. Try to keep a schedule or routine throughout and after the restructure.
- Impact on family and personal life: The financial and emotional strain of a layoff can affect your family, leading to increased tension and potential conflicts (especially if it’s a single income household and they’re about to lose their job). Financial constraints may force changes in lifestyle, such as cutting back on leisure activities, which can affect overall quality of life.
- Reduced future employment prospects: Some employers may view a layoff negatively, associating it with poor performance, even if the layoff was due to broader company issues. The job market can be highly competitive, especially during economic downturns, making it more difficult to secure new employment quickly.
​Must-Know Facts Related to Layoffs, Redundancies and Restructures
1. Resigning is always an option at any point
2. The more “irreplaceable” you can be to a company, the less likely you are to be targeted in a layoff
3. Having said that: long tenure at a workplace does not mean you are safe from layoffs
4. Know that even if you’ve been there for decades, there’s still a risk you get targeted in a restructure (especially if you’re quiet quitting)
7. Try not to take it personally if you do get laid off
8. Triple check that your employer is following the letter of the law
9. If you dodged the restructure, don’t get complacent in your role
10. If you are affected by a restructure, try to push for a redundancy payout in good faith
11. Keep a record of payslips - especially the last pay slip
12. If you have any bonus or shares vesting, ensure you check you’re not leaving anything “on the table” before you leave
13. It usually gets worse before it gets better (in a layoff/job hunting context). Keep your head up
14. If possible, try to do some contracting or take shorter term opportunities
15. Smaller organisations sometimes lay off individual people
16. Take the consultation process seriously
16. If the company wants to get rid of you, they will find a way.
Even if you do everything right:
17. Take full advantage of your support network
18. Think Positive. You’re a survivor and you’re a fighter - you’ll get through this
19. Know when to play the “politics game” and know when it’s time to call it quits
20. While not common, see if your company if open to putting you on garden leave
Employers typically include a garden leave clause in employment agreements to ensure they can enforce it. Without such a clause, the use of garden leave must be mutually agreed upon by the employer and the employee. Sometimes you’ll get a garden leave provision in your employment contract - but it’s still possible to get put on garden leave if you work out an arrangement with your employer.
- You can resign yourself during a proposed restructure (making it easier to explain in future interviews). However, know that you might be giving up any additional severance or redundancy packages given you’d be leaving before the formal consultation and restructure process is completed.
2. The more “irreplaceable” you can be to a company, the less likely you are to be targeted in a layoff
- Just as a sports team wouldn’t cut its best players, a business or government department is unlikely to lay off its most valuable employees. Frontline staff, like doctors, police officers, or firefighters, are generally retained over mid-level managers or bureaucrats. Similarly, a business will prioritise retaining top performers from its best teams or high-performing stores.
3. Having said that: long tenure at a workplace does not mean you are safe from layoffs
- There’s a widely held belief that if you’ve been working at a place for a long time (that you become “part of the woodwork” you’re unlikely to get laid off. While this might apply sometimes, this shouldn’t be the expectation - often, many of the longest standing employees are on much higher salaries and may take their job more “relaxed” given their tenure, leading to complacency.
4. Know that even if you’ve been there for decades, there’s still a risk you get targeted in a restructure (especially if you’re quiet quitting)
- You are not your job. Losing your job does not make you any less valuable or quality as a human.
- Many people struggle with an identity crisis after getting laid off. It’s natural to wrap up your self worth in your job and your ability to generate income - but know that you are not your job. You are far more than the buttons you press on a keyboard or the 9-5 you clock in and out of. You are still valuable - don’t let the negative self talk push you down.
- It won’t always feel this way - but restructures do feel like you’re going through the ringer (meat grinder). Keep your head up and try to stay positive.
7. Try not to take it personally if you do get laid off
- It can be all too easy to backslide into negative thoughts when you’ve been laid off. After all, it’s a highly stressful, emotional and scary period for everyone that goes through it. It’s also easy to pick apart the million different reasons why you specifically have been laid off and try to work out what you could have done differently to avoid this.
- While it’s good to reflect on this experience, do it when you’re in the right headspace (aka NOT while you’re going through the restructure). Remember that often it’s not about you - layoffs happen for all sorts of reasons and usually for reasons outside your control (like external economy or business factors).
8. Triple check that your employer is following the letter of the law
- Due to how clear cut and complex the restructure process is, many employers in New Zealand fail to follow the correct restructure process. Legally, companies cannot restructure you due to poor performance - they must follow the appropriate PIP procedure. If they don’t, they’re potentially opening themselves up to unfair dismissal cases. Make clear this is the case (and if not, talk to an employment lawyer to assess your options).
- If you do suspect your employer isn’t following the right procedure, keep a record of every interaction during the restructure and bring this to an employment lawyer.
9. If you dodged the restructure, don’t get complacent in your role
- Where there’s smoke, there’s fire. Even if you’re super confident in your employment and value/place in the company, don’t get complacent. Restructures can happen at the most unexpected times to the most unexpected people.
10. If you are affected by a restructure, try to push for a redundancy payout in good faith
- While redundancy is not mandated by law (and many contracts may potentially get you to waive any redundancy payouts in the instance you get restructured), some companies may provide a few weeks of redundancy as a sign of good faith.
11. Keep a record of payslips - especially the last pay slip
- Ensure you get your full payout in your final payslip (annual leave, holiday pay, etc.) - and forward this payslip to your PERSONAL email address (given your email access will likely get severed after you leave).
- Many companies can accidentally file the final payroll run incorrectly, especially if there are some unique or special provisions they need to make (out of the ordinary fortnightly or monthly pay run for typical employees).
12. If you have any bonus or shares vesting, ensure you check you’re not leaving anything “on the table” before you leave
- Often, your contract will stipulate specific criteria for when a bonus is paid (or if you work for a startup and employers can sometimes overlook these provisions. If your employer does fail to take this additional compensation into account, you may have grounds to bring a case. Again, document everything and talk to a lawyer if you think your employer has not followed the right process.
13. It usually gets worse before it gets better (in a layoff/job hunting context). Keep your head up
- Generally, layoffs happen at the same time in the economic cycle. More layoffs mean more people applying for the same roles. The more layoffs there are, the harder it will be to get a job. Don’t expect to just get laid off and find a role within the first two weeks of looking - it’s likely going to be very tough (much tougher than when you first started your role).
14. If possible, try to do some contracting or take shorter term opportunities
- Bridging the gap between your current/recent full time employment and your next full time employment gig can be a great way to plug the “gap on your CV” while you keep focusing on job hunting, travel, spending time with family and personal growth.
- Accept that you might have to take “sub-optimal” roles. It doesn't have to be your “forever” role - just an interim role to get you through the transitional period post-layoff. Trying to “bridge the gap” can make it much easier on your finances and career in the long term.
15. Smaller organisations sometimes lay off individual people
- If you’re the only person affected by a layoff and you work in a small company, don’t take it personally. It’s not uncommon for specific people to be targeted in restructures (especially at small companies). While it may seem unfair, it’s still a significant number relative to the total headcount. In other words, a start-up team of ten laying off one person (10%) is “proportionately” the same as MBIE (with around 6,500 employees) laying off 650 people (10%).
16. Take the consultation process seriously
- When it comes to a restructure or layoff, don’t just “roll over and take it”. The company has to genuinely consider the feedback (by law), and if you provide a compelling alternative to the restructure (or point out a fatal flaw in the logic of the business case or rationale for the restructure) the company may have to consider not making employees redundant if another course of action achieves the same result.
16. If the company wants to get rid of you, they will find a way.
Even if you do everything right:
- Create and provide thoughtful feedback.
- Provide alternatives to the restructure.
- Discuss your situation with an independent third party (mediator, lawyer, advisor).
- Work with other affected employees to quasi-unionise.
- You should expect the worst as you still might get laid off. More often than not, companies will consult with an employment lawyer to get their desired outcome (e.g. getting rid of X% of the workforce or XYZ people) but ensure that they are still following the letter of the law and aren’t likely to get sued for wrongful termination/dismissal.
- Ultimately, barring some gross misconduct on your employer’s behalf, your hands might be tied and you may have no other recourse against the company if they’ve followed all the right steps in good faith.
17. Take full advantage of your support network
- You will almost certainly be eligible to bring a “support person” through the process - take your employer up on this. You may be overly emotional during the process and it can help to have a support person there to ensure you don’t miss anything or to help anchor the conversation into a positive or objective tone.
18. Think Positive. You’re a survivor and you’re a fighter - you’ll get through this
- Adopting a survivor mentality can significantly enhance your mood and outcomes when going through a restructure. While creating a plan to endure layoffs requires a realistic approach, maintaining a positive attitude is crucial. You’ll go through many negative conversations and blows to the ego throughout the process - but keeping an open and optimistic mind is a great way to stay motivated.
19. Know when to play the “politics game” and know when it’s time to call it quits
- If you suspect you’re about to get targeted in a restructure, consider “playing the politics game”.
- Playing the game doesn’t mean engaging in office politics or gossip. Instead, it involves adding value and maintaining positivity and engagement at work. Like a sports team, a business is unlikely to cut its top performers unless there’s a significant reason. Be of value, and your importance will shine through, regardless of the economic situation.
- However, if you think your employer already has you in their crosshairs and it’s unlikely anything you do will change this, the “politics game” won’t be worth it and you’re better off spending the effort looking for a new role.
20. While not common, see if your company if open to putting you on garden leave
- Garden leave, while not a common term in New Zealand employment law, refers to a period where an employee who has resigned or been terminated is asked to stay away from work while still receiving full pay and benefits (in other words, they’re paid to sit in their house and do “gardening”).
- During this time, the employee remains bound by their employment contract, including confidentiality agreements and non-compete clauses, but does not perform any work duties. In other words, you can’t start working for another company while on garden leave. Garden leave usually exists to help protect the company's sensitive information and prevents the employee from immediately joining a competitor.
- Although garden leave is not specifically legislated in New Zealand, it is a recognised concept in employment contracts and is often used in circumstances such as:
- Preventing Information Leakage: When an employee has access to commercially sensitive information and might join a competitor, it’s easier to get them to sit at home and not let them see or access any live ongoing deal-related information.
- Maintaining Workplace Harmony: If the employee's presence could disrupt the workplace during the notice period (especially if the rest of the team know you’ve been made redundant and are going to leave, they might feel awkward in the workplace).
- Facilitating a Smooth Transition: Giving the company time to manage the transition without the departing employee's interference in the business.
Employers typically include a garden leave clause in employment agreements to ensure they can enforce it. Without such a clause, the use of garden leave must be mutually agreed upon by the employer and the employee. Sometimes you’ll get a garden leave provision in your employment contract - but it’s still possible to get put on garden leave if you work out an arrangement with your employer.
More details:
Related guides:
- Employment New Zealand
- MBIE Mediation Services
- Employment Relations Authority
- Community Law: Personal Grievance
Related guides: