Bonus Bonds - are they an investment worth having?
Updated: 3 September 2018
Summary of Bond Bonds
- Despite the marketing, each Bonus Bond has a 1 in 3.4 billion chance each month of winning a million dollar prize
- If you hold under $1,000, it’s more likely than not you’ll win nothing over the course of one year
- With inflation running above 2%, Bonus Bonds erode the value of your money as the after-tax return in prize money is around 1.40%
- We believe cashing in Bonus Bonds and put the money in a term deposit is a better investment for anyone wanting a sensible savings option
Bonus Bonds - An Introduction
- If you asked everyone with $1,000 or more invested in Bonus Bonds if they won anything in 2017, most people would tell you no.
- And of that "lucky" bondholders that did win something, 98% of them would have won just $20 or $25.
- Bonus Bonds fully discloses that 99.91% of all prizes awarded are worth $50 or below. And further to that, their website confirms that “we expect that the chance of any Bonus Bond winning a prize will range between 1 in 20,000 to 1 in 35,000” as the government limits the chances of winning a prize to no better than 1 in 9,600.
- In March 2017, Bonus Bonds revealed there are 3.4 billion bonds issued (meaning 3.4 billion dollars). And in the most recent 12 months, it paid $48m in prizes, representing a post-tax 1.4% return on all money invested (and only a 1% return post-tax if you eliminate the twelve $1m winners).
- Bonus Bonds paid itself $46m to manage the scheme, and confirmed you had a 1 in 25,003 chance of winning a prize had you had an investment.
- Given you can currently earn 3.5% per year (pre-tax) in the bank, are Bonus Bonds a bad investment?
- MoneyHub uses a comprehensive statistical methodology to challenge if Bonus Bonds deserve your hard-earned money.
|
It’s a Lottery first, and an investment secondBonus Bonds are an investment, and the interest or return you receive comes down to luck, as it does with any lottery. You can invest or withdraw without penalty, and each bonus bond is worth $1. A bonus bond will not increase or decrease in value, so if you invest $1,000, you buy 1,000 bonds, and will receive $1,000 when you withdraw your investment. Each $1 bond has the same chance of winning a prize. As it is a lottery, the more bonds you hold, the higher chance you have of winning. It's important to know that a bond has the same chance of winning in another draw if it has already won, so a winning bond is still relevant for future prize draws.
What you need to know:
|
|
It’s heavily regulated, but there are risks neverthelessANZ runs Bonus Bonds via their “ANZ Investment Services (New Zealand) Limited” company, and the government heavily regulates it. The government determines the return on investment by setting the maximum odds of winning. Bonus Bonds are mandated to invest your money into cash deposits, and currently invests all its funds in deposits with New Zealand registered banks (50%), bonds issued by New Zealand registered banks (45%) and New Zealand Government debt (5%).
Despite your money sitting with banks and the government, Bonus Bonds is not without its risks. Key risks include:
|
|
The odds of winning a prize are not goodThe exact number of prizes award each month does vary; here is November 2017’s distribution which is typical of an ordinary month.
The table makes one thing clear – the odds are not great. With a $1000 investment, you’re looking at a 1 in 3.4 million chance every month of winning a prize above $5,000. 99.996% of bonus bonds return $0 to their owners. |
|
Every prize is paid out tax-freeBonus Bonds pays all tax on the prizes (the interest), which means whatever you win won’t be treated as income. For bondholders who pay tax, that gives some advantage to the investment. However, despite the overall return on investment being 1.5%, those with average luck won’t win cash prizes anywhere near that rate.
|
|
Bonus Bonds states the annual return is around 1.5%, but for an individual investor, it's much lower.The median prize is $0, which accounts for 99.96% of all bonds. The median cash win is $20, which accounts for 98% of all cash prizes awarded. So, almost every bond wins nothing or at best, next to nothing, with their investment. For every lucky bond that wins $1m, there are 3.4 billion bonds that win nothing.
Estimated cash prizes won over one year with average luck
Assumptions: (1) Chance of winning: 1 in 25,003 per draw (source: Bonus Bonds November 2017 disclosure) (2) Annual chance of winning: 1 in 2084 (i.e. 25,003/12) (3) As 98% of prizes distributed every year are for $20, we've made the assumption that an investor with average luck will only win $20 prizes rather than $1m or other cash prizes. |
|
You can increase your odds...by buying more
|
|
Bonus Bonds markets its cash prizes as “winning” – but it is only a return on your investment.The marketing talks about the wonderful things “Bonus Bonds $1 MILLION winners” do, and the impulse is to invest to “win” big. Yet the cash prizes are merely the interest paid on everyone’s investment. We all know a friend who says “I win with my Bonus Bonds quite often”.
However, if they have $10,000 invested and “win” $75 in a year, the same investment in a bank would “win” $300, and that "win" is guaranteed. Despite this, everyone loves to win things, so there is a strong psychological pull towards keeping money in Bonus Bonds even if the return is relatively poor. |
|
Bonus Bonds are unlikely to beat the inflation rateConsumer prices in New Zealand increased 1.9% year-on-year in the third quarter of 2017, meaning general goods and services cost 1.9% more today than they did this time last year. Bonus Bonds, unlike a term investment, don't pay a guaranteed amount of interest. This means that as inflation increases, your money loses value in real terms. What you could buy for $1,000 last year would cost a lot more next year. Most saving and term investments beat inflation levels, but Bonus Bonds do not.
|
|
If you hold Bonus Bonds for the long term, inflation will eat your investment!If Inflation averages 2.5% over 10 years (since 2000 inflation has averaged around 2.7 percent in New Zealand); in the simplest terms your investment will be worth 25% less if you don't receive any interest on the principal.
For example, if you invest $1,000 in Bonus Bonds for 10 years and don't win anything, you've lost in real terms $250. This can add up the more you invest, eating away at the value of your savings. |
|
How Bonus Bonds compare with other savings and investmentsBonus Bonds compete with other low-risk investments such as term deposits and cash saving offers. It's easy to compare the overall rate of return of Bonus Bonds to other savings. Firstly, the Bonus Bonds cash prize fund rate is currently 1.4% (although this can change at any time, for better or worse to bondholders). Compare this to:
Our table below presents the estimated "return" on Bonus Bonds for differing investment amounts - we know that Bonus Bonds prizes are awarded in set amounts ($20, $50 etc) so we've used some assumptions in our calculation to see how it compares in real terms with the best savings and deposit rates available. How Bonus Bonds compare to cash savings (updated February 2018)
Assumptions (1) For all cash deposits listed, we've used an effective tax rate of 10.5% to calculate the return (2) Given there are fewer than 80 prizes above $500 awarded every month, we've excluded these as a standard bondholder has an almost certain chance of not winning a top prize. In doing so, we calculate an after-tax return of 0.89% *(3) An investor with "average luck" is estimated to win less the stated amounts as the odds of winning a prize are 1 in 25,003 per draw. Furthermore, the nature of Bonus Bonds and the specific prize distributions made (i.e. $20, $50, $5,000) means you cannot win the amounts calculated. |
Concluding Comments - Are Bonus Bonds Worth Your Money?
- Bonus Bonds offer a return on investment that varies depending on your luck. If you are a high-income earner and pay a high rate of tax, they offer tax relief if you win a prize.
- All decent cash deposit deals pay a higher rate of interest and are always going to be significantly more rewarding than Bonus Bonds, unless you have remarkably good luck!
- With the risk of inflation eating away at your investment, you may feel it wiser to pick a bank deposit over the Bonus Bonds. Both investments are equally safe - it just comes down to the expected return.
- Our tables present a fair reflection of the chances of winning. You may decide to invest a little in Bonus Bonds to be in with a chance of winning a million dollar cash prize. That would be perfectly reasonable if you are aware that the odds of winning it are very low (1 in over 3 billion every month per bond held). If you are OK with this, Bonus Bonds are a secure investment.
NB: MoneyHub has used Bonus Bonds' November 2017 prize reporting data as well as statistical methodology first published by MSE UK.
