Compare Income Protection Insurance - 2026 Quotes and Insights
Compare and save on income protection insurance with MoneyHub. We help you find the right policy to protect you and your family, providing all the information you need to make an informed choice and save money.
Updated 17 September 2026
Guide Overhauled - September 2026:
Guide Overhauled - September 2026:
- We've rebuilt this guide from the ground up. It now has quotes from five insurers across 15 occupations, with separate tables for women, men and the self-employed, the same person quoted at 30, 35 and 45, and men and women quoted side by side for the same job.
- We've added a section on ACC versus income protection, a plain-English explanation of indemnity versus agreed value cover, and our findings on where the biggest price gaps sit.
- One thing to know before you compare: Premiums and offers change constantly, so treat every price here as a starting point and confirm with a live quote before you decide.
Summary
Quick policy cost overview and insights:
Do you need income protection insurance? To answer, ask yourself:
If your financial situation would deteriorate without an income, considering an income protection insurance policy is a good idea. To make sense of the pros, cons and costs of income protection insurance, our guide covers:
Find out what income protection costs for your job and salary
Most New Zealanders don't realise how affordable income protection can be - or how much prices vary between insurers. In the next 30 seconds, you can compare real quotes from AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life based on your actual income and occupation.
Know This: Get 20% of your first year's premiums back in cash with LifeDirect
- One in seven New Zealand households has had a serious illness that stopped someone working for three months or more, according to Financial Services Council research.
- Income protection insurance pays a monthly benefit, usually up to 75% of your income, if illness or injury stops you working.
- ACC covers accidents only. Financial Services Council research has found New Zealanders are more than twice as likely to be off work for six months or more because of illness than because of an accident.
- Cancer, mental health conditions and back problems are the most common reasons for long claims, and each can mean months rather than weeks off work.
- This guide helps you find the right policy, from what it costs to how to claim.
Quick policy cost overview and insights:
- Office workers: ~$750 to $950/year for 2-year cover ($100,000 salary, 4-week wait)
- Tradies: ~$1,270 to $1,630/year for the same cover
- Choosing a 13-week waiting period instead of 4 weeks roughly halves the premium - the longer you can wait, the cheaper the cover.
- Most claims are for cancer, mental health, and back problems
Do you need income protection insurance? To answer, ask yourself:
- If something happened to force you to stop work, could you survive on sick pay and/or savings?
- How long would you be able to survive without an income?
If your financial situation would deteriorate without an income, considering an income protection insurance policy is a good idea. To make sense of the pros, cons and costs of income protection insurance, our guide covers:
- What is Income Protection Insurance?
- Understanding ACC vs Income Protection Insurance
- Alternatives Worth Considering
- Must-Know Income Protection Insurance Facts
- Best Income Protection Insurance Policies (for company employees and anyone self-employed)
- Making a Claim on an Income Protection Insurance Policy
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Buying an Income Protection Insurance Policy - Balancing Price and Coverage
Find out what income protection costs for your job and salary
Most New Zealanders don't realise how affordable income protection can be - or how much prices vary between insurers. In the next 30 seconds, you can compare real quotes from AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life based on your actual income and occupation.
Know This: Get 20% of your first year's premiums back in cash with LifeDirect
- Take out income protection through LifeDirect, and they'll pay you a one-off lump sum worth 20% of everything you pay in year one.
- Your policy and premiums stay exactly the same - the cashback is paid on top, straight to your bank account.
- As an example, an office worker paying $800/year gets $160 back, while a tradie on a $2,500/year policy gets $500 back.
- You register through your MyLifeDirect login, and it's paid once your policy has been in force for 13 months. LifeDirect's cashback terms and conditions apply - you can find them on their homepage.
Know This: How we work with LifeDirect, and how this page makes money
- MoneyHub doesn't sell or arrange insurance, so we can't give you a live quote. LifeDirect can: it's a licensed financial advice provider whose tool quotes AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life side by side in about 30 seconds, which is why it appears throughout this guide.
- LifeDirect pays MoneyHub a monthly fee to appear on this page. The fee doesn't change with how many readers get a quote or buy a policy, and we don't receive a commission on any policy sold. No insurer pays to be in our tables or to be shown first.
- We think that matters for how you read this page. We have no reason to push you to buy or to favour one insurer. The 20% cashback is LifeDirect's own offer, paid by LifeDirect. Our advertising policy has the full detail.
Income Protection Insurance in a Nutshell - Our View:
Advertising Disclosure: LifeDirect pays MoneyHub a monthly fee to appear on this page, whether or not you buy a policy. This arrangement has no influence on our independent research or the quotes in our tables, and we encourage all readers to get several quotes before making any decision. Please refer to our advertising policy for more details.
- Income Protection insurance costs vary widely between insurers, so comparing quotes is crucial for getting the best deal. Don’t go directly to an insurer without comparing other quotes to ensure you make an informed decision.
- Everyone’s needs and expectations differ, some might want coverage for two years, while others prefer protection until retirement. The annual cost will also vary significantly based on your chosen payment amount.
- We strongly suggest getting multiple quotes, and LifeDirect offers instant online quotes from multiple leading income protection insurers AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life, all with published financial strength ratings in the A range. Plus, LifeDirect handles claims by liaising with the insurer, making the process hassle-free for you.
Advertising Disclosure: LifeDirect pays MoneyHub a monthly fee to appear on this page, whether or not you buy a policy. This arrangement has no influence on our independent research or the quotes in our tables, and we encourage all readers to get several quotes before making any decision. Please refer to our advertising policy for more details.
​What is Income Protection Insurance?
- If you can’t work due to illness or injury, income protection pays up to 75% of your income, paying out until you return to work, your payment period ends (for example, two years or age 65), you retire or you die, whichever comes first.
- For example, a 35-year-old earning $80,000 might receive $5,000/month if sidelined by an injury, covering essentials like mortgage payments and bills.
- Policies typically start after a waiting period (e.g., 4, 8 or 13 weeks), which lowers premiums the longer you wait. Find out what you'll pay and how much you can get using LifeDirect’s comparison tool which can help find the right policy for your needs.
What does income protection insurance cover?
- While each policy has its own terms, generally injuries and illnesses are covered, and these can be short or long term.
- Income protection insurance is not the same as Critical Illness and Trauma Insurance, which pays out a one-off lump sum (usually between $20,000 and $300,000) if you are diagnosed with a covered illness, or suffer trauma such as a heart attack or stroke etc.
Video Explainer
Our comparison partner LifeDirect explains what income protection covers, focusing on the crucial gap between ACC (which only covers accidents) and the reality that most time off work is due to illness. This foundation video helps you understand why income protection matters. For more videos, please visit our Income Protection Insurance videos summary guide.
Know This: Get 20% of your first year's premiums back in cash with LifeDirect
- Take out income protection through LifeDirect, and they'll pay you a one-off lump sum worth 20% of everything you pay in year one.
- Your policy and premiums stay exactly the same - the cashback is paid on top, straight to your bank account.
- As an example, an office worker paying $800/year gets $160 back, while a tradie on a $2,500/year policy gets $500 back.
- You register through your MyLifeDirect login, and it's paid once your policy has been in force for 13 months. LifeDirect's cashback terms and conditions apply - you can find them on their homepage.
​Understanding ACC vs Income Protection Insurance
ACC is very specific in what it covers, and won't cover illnesses or anything that isn't an injury. If you have an accident and injure yourself, ACC will pay medical costs, physiotherapy treatment and up to 80% of the pre-injury salary is paid until you can return to work. But if the injury is complicated by a pre-existing condition, then all entitlements (care, recovery and compensation) may be denied.
Many New Zealanders are confused by what ACC covers and whether income protection insurance overlaps. Each provides very different benefits, even if they look similar.
Income protection insurance is broader and pays for illness as well as injury. Know this: most policies reduce what they pay by any ACC weekly compensation you receive, so the two don't stack - the value of income protection is the illness cover ACC doesn't provide. Our ACC vs Income Protection guide outlines what you need to know.
Video Explainer
Our comparison partner LifeDirect explains the ACC gap and breaks down real-life scenarios where ACC provides no coverage, ranging from cancer to mental health conditions, illustrating exactly when income protection becomes your financial lifeline. For more videos, please visit our Income Protection Insurance videos summary guide.
Many New Zealanders are confused by what ACC covers and whether income protection insurance overlaps. Each provides very different benefits, even if they look similar.
Income protection insurance is broader and pays for illness as well as injury. Know this: most policies reduce what they pay by any ACC weekly compensation you receive, so the two don't stack - the value of income protection is the illness cover ACC doesn't provide. Our ACC vs Income Protection guide outlines what you need to know.
Video Explainer
Our comparison partner LifeDirect explains the ACC gap and breaks down real-life scenarios where ACC provides no coverage, ranging from cancer to mental health conditions, illustrating exactly when income protection becomes your financial lifeline. For more videos, please visit our Income Protection Insurance videos summary guide.
Alternatives to Income Protection Insurance that are Worth Considering
- WINZ support - Jobseeker Support (health condition or injury) pays a fixed weekly amount; our Jobseeker Support guide has the current after-tax rate for a single person aged 25 or over from April 2026 (the Supported Living Payment, for those unable to work long term, is also available). It's tested against your partner's income, so many two-income households get nothing.
- Relying on savings and/or borrowing from friends or family - if savings run out during a period of illness or injury, relationships with friends and family may be strained if you need to borrow given your inability to pay the money back.
- Trauma and critical illness cover - many common conditions such as a back injury, depression or arthritis don't count as 'critical illness' and therefore won't pay out.
- Life insurance - this pays out if you die or are diagnosed with a terminal illness only, so if you are away from work for six months with a bad back and don't have any other insurance, you would need to rely on your employer's sick pay and/or savings.
We believe trauma and critical illness and life insurance policies should be viewed as complements to income protection and not alternatives given they don't pay out for the same conditions.
Must-Know Income Protection Insurance Facts
Indemnity or agreed value? It changes your payout and your taxAn indemnity policy pays a percentage (usually up to 75%) of what you were earning in the year or two before you claim - if your income has dropped, so does the benefit, but premiums are cheaper and tax-deductible.
An agreed value policy locks in the monthly benefit when you apply, so the insurer can't reduce it later; premiums cost more and aren't deductible, but the payout is tax-free. Self-employed people with variable income often prefer agreed value for the certainty. |
You must have an existing job to apply for income protection insuranceYou can apply for an income protection insurance policy if:
If you have pre-existing medical conditions, you can still apply - insurers may charge you more, and/or exclude any cover and claims related to your existing condition (and possibly related conditions). |
The risk of developing an illness is higher than you thinkFinancial Services Council research has found that one in seven New Zealand households has experienced a serious illness that stopped someone working for three months or more, and that New Zealanders are more than twice as likely to be off work for six months or more because of illness than because of an accident.
The same research found that once sick leave and annual leave ran out, around half of employed New Zealanders could not keep up with their expenses for more than a month. Income protection insurance protects against this risk by paying up to 75% of a policyholder's income until they can return to work, so there is far less disruption to their personal finances. |
Understand that your ability to earn an income is your biggest assetIf you work for forty years and earn an average of $70,000 a year, you have the potential to earn around $2.8 million. This is likely to be more valuable than any property you own. As such, protecting yourself against the inability to earn an income may seem sensible, but the decision to do so will come down to your age, profession, financial commitments and family situation.
For example, a young mother and father of two children are probably more likely to consider income protection insurance than someone in their 50s with a mortgage-free home. |
Self-employed workers have less to fall back on if illness or injury strikesUnlike employees, anyone who is self-employed doesn't have sick pay to fall back on, or a job held open until they recover. Self-employed individuals are the business, and a long-term absence can have devastating effects on the viability of the business.
Income protection insurance can significantly reduce the amount of financial stress for anyone self-employed working by themselves without co-workers to fall back on. |
Redundancy is usually not covered by an income protection policySome insurers may offer it as an optional add-on; it's not standard with most if not all income protection policies. The triggers are illness or injury only, not redundancy or any other restructuring at a workplace. Our guide to Redundancy insurance explains more.
|
You can have more than one income protection policy, but it won't double your payoutInsurers cap the total benefit at around 75% of your income across all policies, and most reduce their payment by whatever another policy (or ACC) pays, so a second policy mostly means paying twice for the same cover.
If you want to remove the worry of not recovering within a 2- or 5-year payment period, choose a policy that pays to age 65 instead. 75% of an income is significant and should cover essential costs while the public health system, or private health insurance, takes care of your treatment and recovery. |
Income protection insurance won't pay out until your sick pay is finishedStatutory sick leave is 10 days a year, and some employers offer much more - up to 12 months at full pay in a few workplaces. Check what you're entitled to before choosing a policy. Most policies won't pay while you're still receiving a salary, so there's no point insuring for a 4-week waiting period if your employer's sick pay runs for 8 weeks.
The longer your sick pay lasts, the longer you can make your waiting period, and the cheaper the policy becomes. |
Best Income Protection Insurance Policies
How to save thousands on income protection insurance over your lifetime:
Disclaimer: Specific income protection policies and their terms and conditions differ between insurers. We make no representation that the quotes below imply that the policies are the same in form and substance. Please review the policies in detail before making any decision. Quotes for AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life were supplied by LifeDirect.
- Never go directly to an insurer. You’ll pay full price and have nothing to compare with so it probably will not be the best deal.
- Instead, start with a comparison website like LifeDirect. They compare the latest prices from five insurers (AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life) and aim to give you all of the relevant information to make a decision.
- If you have a specialist health condition and/or prefer to talk to someone directly, contacting LifeDirect and talking to one of their insurance advisers is a sensible step.
Disclaimer: Specific income protection policies and their terms and conditions differ between insurers. We make no representation that the quotes below imply that the policies are the same in form and substance. Please review the policies in detail before making any decision. Quotes for AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life were supplied by LifeDirect.
Our Quotes
- We obtained quotes from five insurers for two occupations - an office worker and a tradesperson - each aged 35, non-smoking, earning $100,000 and insuring 75% of it ($6,250 a month) with a 4-week waiting period, across four payment periods: 2 years, 5 years, to age 65 and to age 70.
- These tables show how the waiting period and payment period change the price.
- We then quoted 15 occupations on the same basis, changing only the job, with a 13-week waiting period and benefits paid to age 65, in three tables: women (employed), men (employed) and men (self-employed). We then re-quoted three of the employed men with a 2-year payment period.
- These tables show how your occupation changes the price.
- We also quoted the same software developer at 30, 35 and 45 to show the effect of age, and two jobs as both a man and a woman to show how sex changes the premium.
- All quotes were generated on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 and are annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback. Insurers class the same job differently, so one occupation can be a different price, or not offered at all, from one insurer to the next.
Who we quoted:
- Insurers price income protection by occupation, and they price men and women differently.
- Quoting 15 men would give most nurses, teachers and carers the wrong number, so we quoted a woman for five jobs where women are the majority or a large share of the workforce (registered nurse, primary school teacher, hairdresser, accountant and dentist) and a man for the other ten, matching our office worker and tradesperson tables. The women's table is all employees; the men are split into employed and self-employed because insurers quote the two differently.
- Each table's heading says who was quoted. If you're the other sex in your job, the men vs women table further down shows how much the number moves.
Company Employee Income Protection Insurance Policies
1) The Accountant/Office Worker, 35 Year Old Male, Non-Smoker
- $100,000 Annual Salary ($6,250/Month payout - 75% of gross income)
- 4 weeks claim wait period
| Insurer | 2-year payment period | 5-year payment period | Paid to age 65 | Paid to age 70 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Life | $749.26 | $877.74 | $1,426.16 | $1,512.39 |
| Chubb Life | $799.11 | $1,008.58 | $1,510.33 | $1,774.36 |
| AIA | $806.26 | $1,029.11 | $1,729.88 | $1,764.15 |
| Asteron Life | $945.66 | $1,186.50 | $1,741.03 | $1,750.22 |
| Partners Life | $908.44 | $1,076.93 | $1,893.51 | $2,076.41 |
Quotes generated on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 for a 35-year-old male non-smoker, employed, earning $100,000, with 75% indemnity cover ($6,250 a month) and a 4-week wait period. Annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback. Insurers run from cheapest to dearest on the paid-to-age-65 column, and the cheapest quote in each column is in bold.
Self-Employed Income Protection Insurance Policies
2) The Tradesman - Carpenter/Tradesperson (Qualified), 35 Year Old Male, Non-Smoker
- $100,000 Annual Salary ($6,250/Month payout - 75% of gross income)
- Self-employed for over three years
- 4 weeks claim wait period
| Insurer | 2-year payment period | 5-year payment period | Paid to age 65 | Paid to age 70 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Life | $1,269.86 | $1,497.96 | $2,471.76 | $2,624.85 |
| Chubb Life | $1,359.49 | $1,730.91 | $2,620.59 | Not offered |
| Asteron Life | $1,595.34 | $1,953.00 | $2,942.63 | $3,003.00 |
| Partners Life | $1,538.54 | $1,838.35 | $3,291.46 | $3,622.58 |
| AIA | $1,630.26 | $2,111.38 | $3,624.29 | $3,700.06 |
Quotes generated on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 for a 35-year-old male non-smoker, self-employed builder, earning $100,000, with 75% indemnity cover ($6,250 a month) and a 4-week wait period. Annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback. Insurers run from cheapest to dearest on the paid-to-age-65 column, and the cheapest quote in each column is in bold. Not offered: Chubb Life does not offer cover to age 70 for this occupation.
Important: Financial strength - every insurer we compare holds a published financial strength rating in the A range. Our guide to financial strength ratings explains what the grades mean and how to check them.
Important: Financial strength - every insurer we compare holds a published financial strength rating in the A range. Our guide to financial strength ratings explains what the grades mean and how to check them.
Income Protection Quotes by Occupation: Paid to Age 65
- The 15 occupations below span the classes insurers use to price income protection, from the cheapest (software developers, doctors, accountants) to the dearest (electricians, drainlayers, dairy farmers and truck drivers among the men; nurses and hairdressers among the women).
- Every quote is for a 35-year-old non-smoker earning $100,000 with 75% cover of $6,250 a month, a 13-week wait, and benefits paid to age 65. Only the job, and who holds it, changes.
- We chose a 13-week wait because it's what we'd pick for anyone with three months of expenses saved, which is what our emergency fund guide outlines.
- If you have no savings or sick leave, you'll need a 4-week wait and will pay roughly double; the office worker and tradesperson tables above show the 4-week price.
Table 3: Women, employed (35, non-smoker, $100,000, 13 weeks, to 65)
- Primary school teacher - "Teacher - Classroom"
- Registered nurse - "Hospital Employees - Registered Nurse"
- Dentist - "Dentist"
- Hairdresser - "Hairdresser / Barber"
- Accountant - "Accountant - Qualified"
| Occupation | AIA | Asteron Life | Chubb Life | Fidelity Life | Partners Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accountant | $1,349.23 | $1,331.27 | $1,174.83 | $1,147.20 | $1,310.75 |
| Dentist | $1,349.23 | $1,331.27 | $1,174.83 | $1,147.20 | $1,310.75 |
| Primary school teacher | $1,630.63 | $1,749.88 | $1,454.85 | $1,283.07 | $1,557.38 |
| Registered nurse | $2,298.66 | $2,380.02 | $2,020.79 | $1,728.03 | $2,243.27 |
| Hairdresser | $2,298.66 | $2,380.02 | $2,020.79 | $1,728.03 | $2,243.27 |
Table 4: Men, employed (35, non-smoker, $100,000, 13 weeks, to 65)
- Software developer - "Computer Software Engineer"
- Doctor (GP) - "Doctor - (medical degree)"
- Mechanic - "Mechanic (Qualified)"
- Truck or courier driver - "Truck Driver, Light Duty"
- Chef - "Chef / Cook (Qualified)"
| Occupation | AIA | Asteron Life | Chubb Life | Fidelity Life | Partners Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software developer | $883.41 | $914.05 | $758.21 | $742.56 | $889.06 |
| Doctor (medical degree) | $883.41 | $914.05 | $758.21 | $742.56 | $889.06 |
| Mechanic | $1,489.76 | $1,544.88 | $1,279.18 | $1,249.06 | $1,491.35 |
| Chef | $1,489.76 | $1,544.88 | $1,279.18 | $1,249.06 | $1,491.35 |
| Truck or courier driver | $2,122.62 | $2,121.28 | $1,807.02 | $1,624.89 | $2,102.60 |
Table 5: Men, self-employed 3+ years (35, non-smoker, $100,000, 13 weeks, to 65)
- Real estate agent - "Real Estate Agent - Salesperson"
- Electrician - "Electrician - Qualified/Licensed"
- Dairy farmer - "Dairy Farmer/Farm Manager - Supervising employees"
- Builder - "Builder - Carpenter/Tradesperson (Qualified)"
- Drainlayer - "Drainlayer"
| Occupation | AIA | Asteron Life | Chubb Life | Fidelity Life | Partners Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real estate agent | $1,166.05 | $1,158.31 | $931.11 | $876.95 | Not available |
| Builder | $1,775.48 | $1,544.88 | $1,279.18 | $1,249.06 | Not available |
| Electrician | $2,542.40 | $2,121.28 | $1,807.02 | $1,624.89 | Not available |
| Drainlayer | $2,542.40 | $2,121.28 | $1,807.02 | $1,624.89 | Not available |
| Dairy farmer | $2,542.40 | $2,121.28 | $1,807.02 | $1,624.89 | Not available |
Quotes generated on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 for a 35-year-old non-smoker earning $100,000, with 75% indemnity cover ($6,250 a month), a 13-week wait period and benefits paid to age 65. Partners Life did not return a quote for any self-employed profile on these settings.
Income Protection Quotes by Occupation: 2-Year Payment Period
- Our shortlist has three employed men (a mechanic, an electrician and a truck driver) with the payment period cut to 2 years.
- It's the budget option, and for some manual and hospitality jobs it's the only period some insurers will offer - we include it to give an indication of the cost differences.
- All occupations are employed.
| Occupation | AIA | Asteron Life | Chubb Life | Fidelity Life | Partners Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mechanic | $822.85 | $837.56 | $773.68 | $598.06 | $871.49 |
| Electrician | $1,153.07 | $1,128.68 | $1,080.07 | $764.95 | $1,210.42 |
| Truck or courier driver | $1,153.07 | $1,128.68 | $1,080.07 | $764.95 | $1,210.42 |
Quotes generated on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 for a 35-year-old male non-smoker, employed, earning $100,000, with 75% indemnity cover ($6,250 a month), a 13-week wait period and a 2-year payment period. Annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback.
The Age Effect: The Same Software Developer at 30, 35 and 45
Income protection is priced on your age when you apply, and it climbs steeply through your forties. The same software developer, quoted at 30, 35 and 45 with everything else identical, shows why the cheapest year to buy is this one.
| Insurer | Age 30 | Age 35 | Age 45 | Increase, 30 to 45 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Life | $583.07 | $742.56 | $1,266.66 | 117% |
| Chubb Life | $684.31 | $758.21 | $1,305.97 | 91% |
| AIA | $799.37 | $883.41 | $1,424.70 | 78% |
| Partners Life | $863.29 | $889.06 | $1,452.63 | 68% |
| Asteron Life | $781.40 | $914.05 | $1,486.31 | 90% |
The same software developer (man, employed, non-smoker, earning $100,000, 75% indemnity cover, 13-week wait, paid to age 65) quoted on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 at 30, 35 and 45. Annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback. The cheapest quote in each column is in bold.
Men vs Women: The Same Job, Quoted Both Ways
- Insurers in New Zealand price income protection differently for men and women, in the same way they price life insurance differently (where women pay less).
- It's legal under the Human Rights Act, which allows insurers to use actuarial data, and it changes what you'll pay.
- Here the same job is quoted as a man and as a woman with everything else identical: a software developer (a man in the tables above) and a registered nurse (a woman in the tables above).
- The gap is not the same at every insurer, which is one more reason to compare rather than take the first quote.
| Insurer | Software developer, man | Software developer, woman | Registered nurse, man | Registered nurse, woman |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Life | $742.56 | $1,147.20 (+54%) | $1,249.06 | $1,728.03 (+38%) |
| Chubb Life | $758.21 | $1,174.83 (+55%) | $1,279.18 | $2,020.79 (+58%) |
| AIA | $883.41 | $1,349.23 (+53%) | $1,489.76 | $2,298.66 (+54%) |
| Partners Life | $889.06 | $1,310.75 (+47%) | $1,491.35 | $2,243.27 (+50%) |
| Asteron Life | $914.05 | $1,331.27 (+46%) | $1,544.88 | $2,380.02 (+54%) |
Same job, same settings (35, non-smoker, employed, earning $100,000, 75% indemnity cover, 13-week wait, paid to age 65), quoted on LifeDirect on 16 September 2026 as a man and as a woman. Annual premiums including policy fees, before any cashback. The percentage is how much more the woman's quote is than the man's at that insurer. The cheapest quote in each column is in bold.
Our Findings
Across 33 like-for-like comparisons in the eight tables above, key things stood out:
- Fidelity Life was cheapest in all 33. Its margin over the next insurer ranged from 2% (the software developer, where Chubb Life was $16 a year behind) to 41% (an electrician or truck driver on 2-year cover). Chubb Life was second in most comparisons. Gaps that small can reverse with a loading or discount at underwriting, so treat the order as a starting point, not a verdict.
- A 13-week wait roughly halves the premium. For the office class, cover to age 65 cost $743 to $914 a year with a 13-week wait against $1,426 to $1,894 with a 4-week wait: 47% to 53% of the price at every insurer. The self-employed builder showed the same halving. If you have three months of expenses saved, the wait period is the biggest saving on this page.
- 2-year cover costs about half the to-65 price. 45% to 54% at a 4-week wait and 47% to 61% at 13 weeks. Fidelity Life gives the biggest discount for the shorter period and Chubb Life the smallest at a 13-week wait. Five-year cover cost 17% to 30% more than 2 years, and cover to 70 cost between under 1% and 18% more than to 65, with Chubb Life not offering it to the tradesperson at all.
- Insurers price the job's class, not the job. Accountant and dentist were identical at all five insurers; so were nurse and hairdresser, software developer and doctor, mechanic and chef, and electrician, drainlayer and dairy farmer. The cheapest employed man (software developer, $743 at Fidelity Life) and the dearest (truck driver, $1,625) are 2.2 times apart for the same cover.
- Builders are cheaper than electricians. Not what most people expect: the self-employed builder ($1,249 at Fidelity Life) was priced with the employed mechanic, while electrician, drainlayer and dairy farmer ($1,625) were priced with the truck driver, 30% higher.
- Being self-employed doesn't itself raise the price at three insurers. At Fidelity Life, Chubb Life and Asteron Life the self-employed builder cost exactly what an employed mechanic costs, and the self-employed electrician exactly what an employed truck driver costs. AIA charged the self-employed about 20% more in the same class.
- Women pay 38% to 58% more for the same cover. At most insurers the loading is about 50%. Fidelity Life's loading on the nurse (38%) was the smallest, which is why it leads the women's table by a wider margin. The loading is about the size of a jump from office work to a trade: a female teacher's quote ($1,283 at Fidelity Life) is slightly above a male mechanic's ($1,249).
- Premiums roughly double between 30 and 45. The increase ranged from 68% (Partners Life) to 117% (Fidelity Life), and most of it lands between 35 and 45, where every insurer rose by 61% to 72%. Fidelity Life was cheapest at every age despite the steepest climb.
- The dearest quote was 17% to 58% above the cheapest for the same person and cover. The narrowest spreads were the women's office roles (18%) and the 45-year-old developer (17%); the widest were the self-employed electrician (56%) and 2-year cover for a tradesperson (58%). That spread, on identical inputs, is the case for comparing.
Making a Claim on an Income Protection Insurance Policy
If you have to stop work due to an accident or illness, claiming on your income protection insurance policy as soon as possible should be a priority. We've outlined the next steps:
If your claim is rejected, there is other financial support available:
Recovering, and Returning to work
- Contact your insurer - quote your name and policy number, and explain why you'll be out of work and for roughly how long.
- Check whether your premiums are waived while you're on claim - most New Zealand policies include a premium waiver once a claim is accepted. Until the insurer confirms it in writing, keep paying because a lapsed policy stops the payouts.
- Send documents to support your claim - you'll need to provide a medical report, proof of income, e.g. payslips or a bank account statement.
- Wait for the claim to be assessed - the insurer checks your situation against the policy. In some cases, they may ask for more information.
- Accept or challenge the decision - the insurer will either accept your claim and pay you an income, pay a smaller income than what you insured for if your most recent income is lower, or reject your claim. If your claim is accepted, the insurer will keep in contact to check on your recovery progress.
- Dispute a declined claim - complain to the insurer first, and if that fails, take it to the free dispute scheme the insurer belongs to (the IFSO Scheme or FSCL).
If your claim is rejected, there is other financial support available:
- Sick pay: The number of days you have in terms of a payout will depend on your employer's policy, how long you have worked for the organisation and how much you have taken already.
- Work and Income benefits: If you have to leave your job due to your illness, Work and Income offers a number of options.
Recovering, and Returning to work
- While you receive treatment and recover, it's important to check in with your insurer and update them on your progress.
- The insurer can assess the benefit you will receive if you want to return to work at a reduced number of days.
Income Protection Insurance - Frequently Asked Questions
Beyond the list below, our Income Protection Insurance videos summary explains more common questions.
Do you need income protection insurance?
It depends on your personal financial situation. If you developed back problems or an illness like cancer and couldn't work, would you be able to cover your everyday bills and expenses? ACC does not cover lost income due to illness, and Financial Services Council research has found you're more than twice as likely to be off work for six months or more because of illness than because of an accident.
Cancer, heart attacks, strokes and ongoing back pain are all common issues which often result in long periods off work for recovery. Income Protection Insurance steps in to provide a regular amount of money until you are well enough to return to work.
It doesn’t matter whether or not you have children or other dependants - if a period of time off work means you couldn’t pay a mortgage and other bills, income protection insurance is well worth considering. If you have an employer, it's important to check your current sick leave benefits. If the limit is two weeks per year, then there is little safety net should you require more time off work. New Zealanders who are self-employed who don't have sick leave to fall back on are most at risk of being financially worse off should time off work be needed.
You might not need income protection insurance if:
Cancer, heart attacks, strokes and ongoing back pain are all common issues which often result in long periods off work for recovery. Income Protection Insurance steps in to provide a regular amount of money until you are well enough to return to work.
It doesn’t matter whether or not you have children or other dependants - if a period of time off work means you couldn’t pay a mortgage and other bills, income protection insurance is well worth considering. If you have an employer, it's important to check your current sick leave benefits. If the limit is two weeks per year, then there is little safety net should you require more time off work. New Zealanders who are self-employed who don't have sick leave to fall back on are most at risk of being financially worse off should time off work be needed.
You might not need income protection insurance if:
- You could get by on your sick pay; some companies offer full pay at up to 12 months for illnesses, which could cover your immediate weekly costs.
- You have sufficient savings to support yourself for at least 12 months
- You are near to retiring and can rely on KiwiSaver and government superannuation entitlements
- Your partner or family would support you financially while you treat your illness
How much does income protection insurance cost?
The cost of a policy depends on your age, health, and the benefits of the policy. Generally, the more comprehensive the policy, the higher the cost.
The exact cost of a policy is influenced by:
The exact cost of a policy is influenced by:
- Your age
- Your job and annual income
- Your current health, weight and family medical history
- Smoker or non-smoker, or have previously smoked
- The percentage of your income you’d like to cover
- The waiting period before the policy starts to make payments
- The range of illnesses and injuries covered
- The payment period you choose - e.g. two years, five years, or until age 65 or 70.
- Whether you're a man or a woman - women pay more for income protection (see our men vs women table above)
Is there any restriction on what income protection policy payments can be used for?
Quite simply, no. If your claim is successful, you will receive a monthly payment from your insurer. The money is yours to do what you want with it. Most common uses include:
- Paying bills - mortgage, credit cards, electricity and car expenses add up and are far more noticeable if you don't have an income
- Recovery treatments or rehabilitation – you may want to undertake additional or alternative treatments not covered by either your health insurance or the public health system.
- Childcare and home help
- Repaying debt
Do I pay tax on income protection insurance payouts?
It depends on the type of policy. With an indemnity policy (the benefit is based on your income at the time you claim), the premiums are tax-deductible and any payout is taxed as income. With an agreed value policy (the benefit is fixed when you take out the policy), the premiums aren't deductible and the payout is tax-free.
Self-employed people often hold indemnity policies and claim the premiums against their income, which is why their payouts are taxed. Check with your accountant before you choose.
Self-employed people often hold indemnity policies and claim the premiums against their income, which is why their payouts are taxed. Check with your accountant before you choose.
What illnesses are covered by Income Protection Insurance?
Most policies cover a wide range of illnesses, including cancer, back pain, and mental health issues like depression, as well as injuries. Coverage varies by insurer, so it’s crucial to review policy terms for specifics. To get an idea, you can compare options with LifeDirect to ensure your policy meets your health needs.
Can self-employed workers get Income Protection Insurance?
Yes. Premiums depend more on your occupation than on whether you're employed or self-employed: a self-employed accountant pays office-worker rates, while manual trades pay more because the risk of being unable to work is higher.
In our tables above, the builder was quoted well above the office worker at every insurer for the same salary and cover. Being self-employed matters in one way: there's no sick pay to bridge the waiting period, so a shorter wait is worth considering. Policies cover up to 75% of your income. Check your options with LifeDirect’s comparison tool.
In our tables above, the builder was quoted well above the office worker at every insurer for the same salary and cover. Being self-employed matters in one way: there's no sick pay to bridge the waiting period, so a shorter wait is worth considering. Policies cover up to 75% of your income. Check your options with LifeDirect’s comparison tool.
How long does it take to get an Income Protection payout?
Benefits are usually paid monthly in arrears once your waiting period has ended and the claim is approved. With a 4-week waiting period, that typically means your first payment lands around eight weeks after you stopped work; with an 8-week wait, around 12 weeks, and with a 13-week wait, around 17 weeks.
Know This: Get 20% of your first year's premiums back in cash with LifeDirect
- Take out income protection through LifeDirect, and they'll pay you a one-off lump sum worth 20% of everything you pay in year one.
- Your policy and premiums stay exactly the same - the cashback is paid on top, straight to your bank account.
- As an example, an office worker paying $800/year gets $160 back, while a tradie on a $2,500/year policy gets $500 back.
- You register through your MyLifeDirect login, and it's paid once your policy has been in force for 13 months. LifeDirect's cashback terms and conditions apply - you can find them on their homepage.
Concluding Comments: Buying an Income Protection Insurance Policy - Balancing Price and Coverage
- Income protection insurance costs vary widely between insurers, so compare before you buy and never go to an insurer without other quotes in hand. Everyone's needs differ: some want cover for two years, others want it to retirement, and the price moves with the benefit amount, the waiting period and the payment period you choose.
- Across our tables the dearest quote was 17% to 58% above the cheapest for the same person and the same cover; that range is why comparing AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life is worth the effort.
- Don't be tempted by a cheap policy with a lot of exclusions - life is unpredictable, and you want a policy that clearly covers you for as many illnesses and injuries as possible.
- If in doubt, talk to an adviser (such as LifeDirect, or anyone else you trust) - they work with you to find the policy that suits your situation. LifeDirect also assists with claims by liaising with the insurer on your behalf.
Important: Why doesn't LifeDirect's tool quote every insurer?
Our View: Every insurer in the tables above holds a published financial strength rating, and the list above sets out exactly who's missing and why, so you can weigh that for yourself.
- LifeDirect's live tool quotes five insurers: AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life. It only works with insurers that sell through independent advisers, meet financial strength requirements, offer transparent underwriting and provide reliable claims service. Here's who isn't included, and why:
- Direct-only insurers - Pinnacle Life and AA Life (whose policies are underwritten by Asteron Life) sell direct to the public rather than through advisers, so they aren't on LifeDirect's panel.
- Bank-branded policies - No major bank underwrites its own cover any more, and bank-branded policies (including SBS's, underwritten by Chubb Life) are only sold through the bank, so there's no independent way to compare their pricing.
- Resolution Life - Its book of older policies is closed to new customers. Asteron Life, in the same group, is open and included; the two are due to come together as Acenda Life from 2027.
- Smaller and niche insurers - Specialty providers are too small to be suitable for the wider New Zealand market.
Our View: Every insurer in the tables above holds a published financial strength rating, and the list above sets out exactly who's missing and why, so you can weigh that for yourself.